A three judge panel Friday found 41 year old Gurpreet Singh guilty on all charges in the 2019 shooting deaths of his wife, her parents, and her aunt. Prosecutors say Singh methodically shot the victims at their West Chester apartment. The judges re-convened Monday for the penalty phase of the trial, where they will determine whether Singh should be given the death penalty, or life in prison. The first trial in 2022 ended with a hung jury.